Healthcare Training Institute - Quality Education since 1979
CE for Psychologist, Social Worker, Counselor, & MFT!!
In the last section, we discussed the various triggers of defensive anger in BPD clients. These triggers are criticism; fear of unworthiness; and helplessness.
As you already know, anger for most BPD clients results from a certain need not being met. The pain that the client feels will most often produce angry outbursts because the client has not yet learned a less aggressive response. To remedy this, I give my clients response choices to express their needs without resorting to anger.
Three Active Response Choices
♦ #1 Expressing a Specific Need
To ask someone to be more loving, responsible, or caring is a broad request and, I have found, frequently leads to disappointment and miscommunication. Instead, I asked Lucy to be specific about the certain actions she wishes the other person to take. Also, I asked Lucy to have a fallback position, or the minimal behavioral change she would compromise with. Lucy was upset with her boyfriend because he kept setting up dates with friends that she did not like.
Lucy stated, "I always feel pressured around them, and unsure of myself. I really wish John wouldn’t invite them along." To express to John her feelings without the use of anger, Lucy stated, "What bothers me is you’re making dates with people I’m not sure I want to see. What I’d like is for you to check with me first before making any arrangements." As a fallback position, Lucy asked John to at least tell his friends that she might not be able to come along. As you can see, by stating her needs rationally rather than aggressively, Lucy accomplished her goal and her relationship remained intact.
♦ #2 Negotiating
I asked Jill to remember that when working toward a compromise, each person’s needs must be met. I suggested to Jill that if Kyle suggested a worthless or resistant position, to offer a fallback proposal. However, if his suggestion had potential, to begin to negotiate. I gave Jill some suggestions to keep in mind when negotiating.
Again, Kyle resisted. Jill then presented her fallback position, "How about at least visiting twice a week, forget bringing dinner?" Again Kyle refused, but suggested paying a service to bring their mother dinner. Jill consented to this, but also stated, "But she also needs to see you. How about you pay for someone two nights a week, and you visit once a week?" Kyle consented to this.
Jill later stated to me, "It was great. I didn’t get angry because I knew the whole time something was actually going to get done. I had to tell myself that this way was better, even though I still kind of wanted to get angry." As you can see, Jill also accomplished her goal through an active response.
Think of your Jill. Could he or she benefit from negotiating?
♦ #3 Ultimatums
Typical ways which this response can be used is: paying someone else to do it; doing it themselves; getting the help of an authority figure; withdrawing from the relationship (either temporarily or permanently); or getting the need met elsewhere. Toby was a 23 year old BPD client who responded to peer pressure with anger.
Toby stated, "Around my friend Jared, I always feel pressured to impress him. I know he doesn’t mean it, but when I feel like he’s going too far, I get angry and call him a bastard and whatnot." I asked Toby to try issuing an ultimatum the next time he felt Jared was encroaching on Toby’s self-esteem. This occurred when, during dinner, Jared began to pressure Toby to go to a strip-club.
Toby found this distasteful, and told Jared he did not want to go. Jared began to taunt Toby, calling him a faggot and questioning his sexuality. At last, Toby issued this ultimatum, "Jared, if you press me again about the strip club, I’m going to just pay the bill and leave. We’ll go bowling tomorrow, but I’ll pack it in for the night." Jared took Toby at his word and dropped the matter. By issuing an ultimatum in this case, Toby was able to retain his anger from flaring up. Think of your Toby. Could he or she benefit from issuing an ultimatum?
In this section, we presented active response choices for BPD clients, which included expressing a specific need; negotiating; and ultimatums.
In the next section, we will examine passive response choices for BPD clients, which include getting information; acknowledging; and withdrawal. Also, we will include Guidelines for All Response Choices.
Peer-Reviewed Journal Article References: