Questions? 800.667.7745; Voice Mail: 925-391-0363
Add To Cart

Section 21
Stress as a Determinant & Consequence of Infertility

Question 21 | Answer Booklet | Table of Contents | Printable Page

One in six couples will experience fertility problems at some time in their lives, and only one-half will succeed in becoming pregnant (Seibel, 1997). Infertility rates are projected to increase during the next 20 years as the age distribution of the U.S. population reflects the passing of the baby boom generation through middle age (Chandra & Stephen, 1998). Also, a cohort of couples may have delayed childbearing because of financial and career considerations. If projections prove accurate, many will face fertility problems and complex decisions regarding the use of reproductive technologies, often associated with considerable physical, emotional, and financial cost (Greenfeld, 1997).

Infertility has been associated with substantial levels of stress, generally attributed to its indeterminate and often prolonged time frame and the uncertainty and ambiguity of the diagnosis and treatment process. Infertility is variable in time, and with treatment, can span more than a decade, the average being five years (Domar & Seibel, 1997). For example, by the time a couple initiates an in vitro procedure, they may have been infertile for up to six years and in treatment for four (Boivin, 2003). Infertility treatment has been found to have consequences for subsequent health functioning, quality of life, and psychological well-being during presumed childbearing years (Shapiro, 1982). People may feel depleted, isolated, and vulnerable to the experience of prolonged stress (Valentine, 1986). Research in other populations suggests that psychosocial factors may play a role in mediating or moderating stress appraisal and its consequences.

Stress Associated with Infertility Treatment
The impact of stress on health and the disease process has been established for some time (House, 1987). Although substantial stress has been associated with infertility, systematic research examining the way that stress may affect the reproductive system has not received the level of attention focused on other physiological processes (Kelly, Hertzman, & Daniels, 1997). Stress associated with infertility is increasingly considered both a determinant and a consequence of reduced fertility (Klonoff-Cohen, Chu, Natarajan, & Sieber, 2001). Although no clear pattern has emerged, studies investigating changes in psychoendocrine stress response during in vitro fertilization have found physiological alterations associated with stress (Facchinetti, Matteo, Artini, Volpe, & Genazzani, 1997). 

Factors Associated with Variation in Infertility-Related Stress
Psychosocial factors associated with stress in other populations include social support and self-esteem (Cohen, Kessler, & Gordon, 1995; Thoits, 1995). However, their influence on infertility-related stress is relatively unknown (Stanton & Dunkel-Schetter, 1991). As suggested by Daniels (1993), stress has generally been considered a psychological rather than a psychosocial phenomenon, and attention to social factors that might affect a couple has been neglected. Help has therefore been focused on the couple experiencing the fertility problem, to the exclusion of their social networks and treatment teams (Blyth, 1999). The role of perceived support in stress reduction in infertile couples has been insufficiently addressed, particularly over time (Gibson & Myers, 2002). It may be that the secrecy, withdrawal, and social isolation, often part of the infertility experience, affect perceived and received support (Sandelowski, Holditch-Davis, & Harris, 1990). In addition, support may vary over time (Jirka, Schuett, & Foxall, 1996).

There are gender differences in obtaining support (Daniluk, 1997; Kowalcek, Wihstutz, Buhrow, & Diedrich, 2001). For example, Band and colleagues (1998) found that failure to seek support was among the most significant predictors of distress among infertile men. Stress levels in general are higher for women, as they tend to take greater responsibility for the problem even when the cause is unknown (Greil, 1991). Because more is known about the female reproductive system, women experience more treatment procedures; the complexity of juggling work, family, and treatment responsibilities may increase stress for women (Hurwitz, 1989).

Reduced self-esteem has been found to be both a consequence of infertility and a covariate in adjustment to it (Fleming & Burry, 1988). For example, Bernstein and colleagues (1988) and Greenfeld (1997) concluded that damage to self-esteem was a major component of the infertility experience. Perceived health has been shown to predict future health and mortality (Idler & Angel, 1990). It is possible that the chronic nature of infertility influences perceived health in the years following an infertility diagnosis, and conversely, that perceived health affects the overall stress of the experience. Stage of treatment may also affect perceived stress. Because the probability of treatment failure with repeated in vitro fertilization procedures is high, intervention at almost any time in the process may be useful (Bergart, 2000; Black, Walther, Chute, & Greenfeld, 1992).

Despite long-standing involvement of social workers in adoption and child welfare settings, emotional investment in biological children has infrequently been considered a factor in infertility-related stress (Henning & Strauss, 2002; Holbrook, 1990). It is possible that substantial investment in biological parenting may negatively affect self-esteem when conception does not occur, which may ultimately influence stress appraisal (Matthews & Matthews, 1986). Identification of factors found to be negatively associated with stress may ultimately help both the couples and the individuals who work with them.

Psychosocial evaluations can be performed to determine a couple's ability to tolerate the effects of a potentially protracted treatment process and appropriate support recommended when indicated (Covington, 1988). Support from medical staff may be useful at the time of initial diagnosis and with extended treatment failure (Boivin, 2003). In consideration of the important role of the physician--patient relationship, patients and treatment teams should strive to maintain open rapport throughout the course of treatment. With their psychosocial perspective, social workers are in a position to facilitate an open communication process.

Interventions designed to help couples maintain emotional balance while pursuing infertility treatment may be beneficial. At the broader level, education by social workers of physicians and others to promote increased understanding of the infertility experience can be instrumental in facilitating sensitive medical and mental health practice and in contributing to thoughtful and ethical policies regarding the use of reproductive technology.
- Schneider, Myra G., Forthofer, Melinda S.; Associations of Psychosocial Factors with the Stress of Infertility Treatment; Health & Social Work; Aug 2005; Vol. 30; Issue 3.
The article above contains foundational information. Articles below contain optional updates.

Personal Reflection Exercise #7
The preceding section contained information about stress and infertility treatment.  Write three case study examples regarding how you might use the content of this section in your practice.

What is the effect of stress on infertility? Record the letter of the correct answer the Answer Booklet.

Answer Booklet for this course
Forward to Section 22
Back to Section 20
Table of Contents

The article above contains foundational information. Articles below contain optional updates.
More Articles on 50+ topics
Book Review: Radical Acceptance: The Secret to Happy, Lasting Love - October 06, 2017
At the heart of all advice about how to have better relationships, resolve conflict, improve connection, and enhance intimacy is the idea of simply learning to accept others for who they are. […]
When an Out of Control Mindset Hijacks the Steering Wheel - October 05, 2017
Whether it’s in the news or our personal lives, we bear witness to people continuing to engage in compulsive, self-defeating behaviors despite the obvious negative or destructive effects. Sometimes it […]
8 Small Shifts that Significantly Enhance Your Life - September 30, 2017
Sometimes, we need to make big changes in our lives. We need to take a different job. We need to sell our home and downsize. We need to move to […]
How to Cope with Shame - September 29, 2017
A salesman started seeing psychotherapist Greg Struve, LAC, SEP, because he feared he was getting fired from his current position. The fear was legitimate: He’d been there for almost 18 […]
When a Narcissist Is Also Codependent - September 10, 2017
Writers often distinguish narcissists and codependents as opposites, but surprisingly, though their outward behavior may differ, they share many psychological traits. In fact, narcissists exhibit core codependent symptoms of shame, […]